IRS Notice of Deficiency: What the 90-Day Letter Means and What to Do Now

Kugelman Law

Quick answer: An IRS Notice of Deficiency is the formal notice that the IRS intends to assess additional tax. It is often called the “90-day letter” because you generally have 90 days (150 if it is addressed to you outside the United States) to petition the U.S. Tax Court.

If you petition on time, the IRS cannot assess or collect the disputed amount while the case is pending, and you can challenge it without paying first. If you do nothing, the tax is assessed and collection begins. Call (415) 968-1780 for a privileged consultation.

A Notice of Deficiency is the most important letter in an IRS dispute. It is the last stop before the IRS can bill you, and it is the document that opens the door to the U.S. Tax Court.

This guide explains how to recognize the notice, how to find your real deadline, what your options are, and how to spot weaknesses in the IRS’s case before you respond.

What is an IRS Notice of Deficiency?

A Notice of Deficiency (sometimes called a “statutory notice of deficiency” or “SNOD”) is the IRS’s formal determination that you owe more tax than you reported. The law requires the IRS to send it before it can assess most additional income tax.

The notice usually arrives after an audit, a computer mismatch with third-party reporting, or a return the IRS prepared for you. Common versions include:

  • Letter 3219: commonly issued after an audit handled by mail.
  • Letter 531: commonly issued after an in-person (office or field) audit.
  • Notice CP3219A: issued by the IRS’s automated matching program, often after an unresolved CP2000 notice.

Whatever the number, the notice will state the proposed tax and penalties, explain your right to petition the Tax Court, and print the last day you can file.

Is your letter actually a Notice of Deficiency?

Many IRS letters look urgent, but only a Notice of Deficiency starts the 90-day Tax Court clock. Here is how the common letters compare:

LetterWhat it isTax Court right?
CP2000A proposed change based on third-party reporting.No. Respond by the stated date to avoid a Notice of Deficiency.
30-day letter (often with an audit report)The examiner’s proposed adjustments, with an offer of IRS Appeals.No. It is your chance to request Appeals before a Notice of Deficiency.
Letter 3219, Letter 531, CP3219ANotice of Deficiency.Yes. Petition by the last day printed on the notice.
CP14 or other balance-due noticeA bill for tax that has already been assessed.No. The deficiency stage has passed; collection rules apply.

If you are unsure what you received, treat it as a Notice of Deficiency until a professional confirms otherwise. Guessing wrong in the other direction can cost you your right to Tax Court.

Finding your deadline on the Notice of Deficiency

Your deadline is the “last day to petition the Tax Court” printed on the notice. Rely on that date rather than counting 90 days yourself.

A few rules matter here:

  • The IRS cannot extend it. Calling the IRS, sending documents, or asking for reconsideration does not stop the clock.
  • Electronic filing has a time cutoff. A petition filed electronically must be filed by 11:59 p.m. Eastern Time on the last day.
  • Weekends and holidays. If the last day falls on a weekend or a Washington, D.C. legal holiday, the petition is generally timely on the next business day.

For Californians, there is less room for error than in some other states. The Ninth Circuit, which covers California, treats the 90-day deadline as jurisdictional, so a petition filed even one day late is dismissed. Courts are still ruling on this question, so check for recent decisions or ask an attorney.

Your options after an IRS Notice of Deficiency

Once the notice arrives, you have four realistic paths:

  1. Agree. If the adjustments are correct, you can sign Form 5564, the Notice of Deficiency waiver, and the IRS will assess the tax.
  2. Petition the U.S. Tax Court. You dispute the adjustments without paying first, and the IRS cannot assess the contested amount while the case is open.
  3. Do nothing. After the deadline passes, the IRS assesses the tax, penalties, and interest, and collection notices follow. See IRS tax collections.
  4. Pay and seek a refund. You pay the full amount, file a refund claim, and, if it is denied, sue in federal district court or the Court of Federal Claims.

For most people who disagree with the notice, the petition is the strongest option. It preserves every argument, keeps the money in your hands, and creates real settlement pressure.

What is behind the notice: how the IRS built its case

A Notice of Deficiency is only as strong as the examination file behind it. That file usually includes the revenue agent’s report, workpapers, and a record of what you did or did not provide.

Co-author Otto Bosch spent years as an IRS Revenue Agent building exactly these files. When we review a Notice of Deficiency, we look for the places they tend to be weakest:

  • Estimates and reconstructions that fill gaps in the record with assumptions instead of evidence.
  • Evidence the examiner never considered, including documents that arrived late or were never requested.
  • Penalty procedures, such as whether the required written supervisory approval was obtained before penalties were asserted.
  • Timing, including whether the notice was issued within the IRS’s statute of limitations for assessment.
  • Legal conclusions that misapply the rules, which is common with credits, deductions, and digital assets.

Each weakness becomes an argument in the petition, and each argument becomes leverage in settlement.

Why a Tax Court petition usually beats arguing by letter

After a Notice of Deficiency, more letters to the IRS rarely change the outcome. The examiner has finished, and the deadline keeps running.

Filing a petition changes who is evaluating your case. Many docketed cases are referred to the IRS Independent Office of Appeals, and an IRS Chief Counsel attorney has to decide whether the agency’s position will survive in front of a judge.

That is where cases settle. In one matter, two IRS Notices of Deficiency proposed more than $557,000 in tax and penalties across six years, and we settled the case in U.S. Tax Court down to roughly $38,000 in federal liability.

With avoided interest and California exposure, the client effectively saved over $1.2 million. Results depend on specific facts. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

Our U.S. Tax Court practice explains the full petition-to-trial process.

Common reasons the IRS issues a Notice of Deficiency

The notices we see most often come from a handful of situations:

  • Disallowed credits and deductions, including residential solar and other energy credits, often because the IRS wants documentation that is hard to obtain years later.
  • Unreported income flagged by third-party reporting, including brokerage, payment-app, and cryptocurrency activity. See our cryptocurrency accounting and audits practice.
  • Audit adjustments where the taxpayer could not fully substantiate business expenses. See IRS audit defense.
  • Substitute-for-return assessments, where the IRS prepared a return for an unfiled year using only the income it knew about. See unfiled tax returns.

Interest, deposits, and the California follow-up

Interest on a deficiency generally keeps running while you dispute it. In some cases, a taxpayer can make a deposit with the IRS to stop interest from growing on the amount deposited while still contesting the tax.

California residents should also plan for the state. If a federal change becomes final, California generally requires you to report it to the Franchise Tax Board within six months, either conceding it or explaining why it is wrong.

That is one reason the federal outcome matters so much: a smaller federal adjustment usually means a smaller California one.

What to do this week if you received a Notice of Deficiency

  1. Find the “last day to petition” date on the notice and put it on your calendar.
  2. Gather the file: the notice, any audit report, prior IRS letters, and everything you sent the IRS.
  3. Do not rely on calls or letters to the IRS to protect your rights; they do not extend the deadline.
  4. Get a privileged review of the notice and the examination file before you decide to agree, petition, or pay.
  5. File the petition early rather than on the last day, especially if you are in California.

If you have already filed a petition on your own, an attorney can still enter the case. Our Tax Court attorneys regularly step into pending cases.

Talk to a U.S. Tax Court attorney about your Notice of Deficiency

If you received an IRS Notice of Deficiency, the next few weeks decide your options. Schedule a paid, privileged consultation with Kugelman Law by calling (415) 968-1780 or visiting our contact page.

Talk to a Tax Attorney

Get clear, confidential answers about your tax situation.

Schedule a paid, privileged consultation with Kugelman Law. Everything you share is protected by attorney-client privilege.

Frequently asked questions

Is a Notice of Deficiency a bill?

No. It is a proposed assessment that gives you the right to go to Tax Court before the IRS can bill you. If you do not petition by the deadline, the IRS assesses the tax and then sends a bill.

Can the IRS extend the 90-day deadline?

No. The IRS cannot extend the time to petition the Tax Court, and sending the IRS more documents does not pause the clock. Rely on the last day printed on the notice.

Can I still go to IRS Appeals after a Notice of Deficiency?

Generally, yes, by filing a Tax Court petition first. Many docketed cases are then referred to the IRS Independent Office of Appeals for settlement discussions.

Do I have to pay the tax before petitioning the Tax Court?

No. The Tax Court lets you challenge a deficiency without paying it first. Interest generally continues to accrue, so some taxpayers make a deposit to limit interest while they litigate.

What happens if I ignore a Notice of Deficiency?

After the deadline passes, the IRS assesses the tax, penalties, and interest, and collection follows. Your options become narrower and usually require paying first.

Does a federal Notice of Deficiency affect my California taxes?

Often, yes. When a federal change becomes final, California generally requires you to report it to the Franchise Tax Board within six months, and the state may adjust your California return to match.

About the authors

Alex Kugelman is the founder and managing attorney of Kugelman Law and a former judicial law clerk at the U.S. Tax Court in Washington, D.C. (2012–2014). He has nearly two decades of federal tax controversy experience, including U.S. Tax Court and U.S. District Court litigation.

Alex is admitted in California and before the U.S. Supreme Court, the U.S. Tax Court, and the U.S. District Courts for the Northern and Eastern Districts of California. He was quoted in the Financial Times and the New York Post in July 2026 on California’s proposed billionaire tax and residency audits.

Otto Bosch is a tax controversy attorney at Kugelman Law and a former IRS Revenue Agent from the Global High Wealth group of the IRS Large Business & International Division.

Otto is admitted to practice before the U.S. Tax Court and in Missouri, has been an IRS Enrolled Agent since 2024, and holds an LL.M. in Taxation. He was quoted in Tax Notes in 2026 on IRS examination training and the LB&I audit campaign targeting deferred legal fee structures.

This article is attorney advertising and general information, not legal advice. Deadlines and options depend on the specific notice and facts. Contacting Kugelman Law does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Client Reviews

Alex, Grace and Jon are the best crypto tax team you could hope for! They can tackle hugely complex, nightmarish tax cases with relative ease. They’re incredibly talented professionals who really know what they’re doing. I only wish I knew about Kugelman Law sooner!

Dave

Alex was more than helpful in helping me figure out some complicated cryptocurrency-related tax issues. Had detailed knowledge of where the IRS currently stands on crypto-related issues.

Alexander Dishes

Kugelman Law is outstanding! I highly recommend their services! The team members all work together in a professional, knowledgeable, caring, kind, and compassionate manner. Alex is an amazing attorney who approaches challenging tasks with patience, optimism and efficiency, and we are so grateful for...

Betsy Lance

Visit Us

Marin County Office
1005 A Street
Suite 207

San Rafael, CA 94901

San Francisco Office *by appointment only
2 Embarcadero Center
8th FL

San Francisco, CA 94111

Irvine Office *by appointment only
300 Spectrum Center Dr
#400

Irvine, CA 92618

Los Angeles Office *by appointment only
633 West Fifth Street
28th Floor

Los Angeles, CA 90071

Contact Us Now

Fill out the contact form or call us at (415) 968-1780 to schedule your consultation.

Leave Us a Message