- Contact Us Now: (415) 968-1780 Tap Here To Call Us
Are Attorney Fees Taxable in a Settlement? What Eiler Means for Plaintiffs
Quick answer: Often, yes. If your settlement is taxable, the portion paid to your lawyer under a contingent fee is generally your income too, even if the money went straight to the lawyer.
Some claims allow an offsetting deduction, but many do not, and a July 2026 Tax Court decision, Eiler v. Commissioner, shows how costly the gap can be. Call (415) 968-1780 for a paid, privileged consultation.
Are attorney fees taxable in a settlement? For many plaintiffs, this is the single most expensive surprise in the tax treatment of a lawsuit.
The rule can mean paying tax on money you never received. This article explains where the rule comes from, which claims still allow a deduction, what the Tax Court decided in Eiler, and what to do before you sign.
Are attorney fees taxable in a settlement? The basic rule
In Commissioner v. Banks (2005), the U.S. Supreme Court held that when a plaintiff’s recovery is taxable income, the portion paid to the plaintiff’s attorney under a contingent fee agreement is generally included in the plaintiff’s gross income.
The reasoning is that the claim belongs to the client. Agreeing in advance to pay part of the recovery to a lawyer is treated as the client earning the income and then paying a fee.
Here is a simple example. A plaintiff settles a taxable claim for $500,000 and the lawyer’s contingent fee is 40%. The plaintiff receives $300,000 but generally has $500,000 of income, unless a deduction for the $200,000 fee is available.
Why the fee deduction matters more than ever
Before 2018, many plaintiffs could deduct legal fees as a miscellaneous itemized deduction. That deduction was limited and often reduced by the alternative minimum tax, but it helped.
The 2017 tax law suspended miscellaneous itemized deductions from 2018 through 2025. The 2025 tax law known as the One Big Beautiful Bill Act made that suspension permanent.
As a result, if your fees do not qualify for an above-the-line deduction, there is generally no fallback. You may simply be taxed on the gross amount.
Which claims still allow an above-the-line deduction
Congress created an above-the-line deduction for attorney fees in certain kinds of cases. “Above the line” means the deduction reduces your adjusted gross income directly, so the itemized-deduction limits do not apply.
The deduction is generally available for fees and costs paid in connection with:
- Unlawful discrimination claims, a term the tax code defines to include a long list of federal civil rights and employment statutes, plus a catchall for laws regulating the employment relationship.
- Certain whistleblower awards, including IRS whistleblower awards and claims under the federal False Claims Act.
The deduction is generally capped at the amount of income from the case that you include in the same tax year. It is meant to keep you from being taxed on the fee, not to create an extra loss.
Fees connected with a trade or business, such as a business owner’s commercial dispute, are generally deductible as business expenses. The hardest cases are personal claims that are taxable but fall outside these categories.
Eiler v. Commissioner (July 2026): are attorney fees taxable in a settlement with no allocation?
In Eiler v. Commissioner, 167 T.C. No. 3 (July 14, 2026), the U.S. Tax Court addressed a settlement of Fair Credit Reporting Act claims against consumer reporting agencies.
The settlements were paid as lump sums with no allocation among damages, fees, and costs. Most of the money went to the taxpayers’ lawyers, and the taxpayers reported only the small amount they personally received.
The court held that:
- The full settlement was taxable income to the taxpayers, including the portion paid directly to their lawyers.
- The silent agreement did not help. With no allocation, the payment was presumed taxable.
- No above-the-line deduction was available. The court read the “civil rights” language in the unlawful discrimination definition narrowly and concluded the credit reporting claims did not qualify.
The court acknowledged that the result was harsh but said it could not change the basic rules of income tax to avoid it. Because Eiler is a reported Tax Court opinion, the IRS and other taxpayers can be expected to rely on it.
Who should pay attention to Eiler
Eiler involved consumer credit reporting claims, but its lessons reach further. Plaintiffs are most exposed when:
- The claim is taxable and personal, not related to a business.
- The claim falls outside the employment, discrimination, and whistleblower categories.
- Fees are a large share of the recovery, as in many fee-shifting and consumer cases.
- The settlement agreement does not allocate the payment.
Common examples include defamation, privacy, consumer protection, and some contract and fraud claims. Whether a particular claim fits a deductible category is a legal question that should be analyzed before settlement.
What you can do before you sign
There is no way to make taxable damages tax-free by drafting alone. There are legitimate steps that can reduce exposure when they match the facts:
- Analyze every claim in the case. If a complaint includes a bona fide employment or discrimination claim, a properly supported allocation to that claim may support the above-the-line deduction.
- Allocate the settlement expressly. An arm’s-length allocation that matches the record is generally respected and avoids the presumption that hurt the taxpayers in Eiler.
- Separate excludable damages. If any part of the recovery is for a physical injury, that portion and its related fees may be outside the problem entirely.
- Consider capital recovery. In some cases, part of a recovery may be treated as a return of basis rather than income.
- Model the net result. Compare your after-tax recovery at different settlement numbers before you accept one.
Our Settlement Tax Review addresses each of these questions alongside your litigation counsel. For the bigger picture on how each type of recovery is taxed, see are lawsuit settlements taxable?
Reporting attorney fees on your return
When a defendant pays a taxable settlement, it often issues a Form 1099 to you for the full amount, including the portion paid to your lawyer. Your lawyer may receive a Form 1099 for the same money.
That double reporting does not mean the income is taxed twice. It does mean you need to report the settlement correctly and, if a deduction is available, claim it in the same year.
If you have already settled and are unsure how to report it, get advice before you file. A mismatch between your return and a Form 1099 is a common trigger for IRS notices.
If the IRS has already challenged your settlement
If you received a notice proposing tax on settlement proceeds or attorney fees, the deadlines matter. A Notice of Deficiency gives you a limited window to petition the U.S. Tax Court without paying the tax first.
We represent clients through IRS examinations and in the U.S. Tax Court, where both of our attorneys are admitted to practice.
Talk to a tax attorney before you settle
After Eiler, the tax treatment of attorney fees deserves attention in every taxable settlement. The time to address it is before the agreement is signed.
Schedule a paid, privileged consultation by calling (415) 968-1780 or visiting our contact page.
Talk to a Tax Attorney
Get clear, confidential answers about your tax situation.
Schedule a paid, privileged consultation with Kugelman Law. Everything you share is protected by attorney-client privilege.
Frequently asked questions
Are attorney fees taxable in a settlement?
Often, yes. If the settlement is taxable, a contingent fee paid to your lawyer is generally included in your income under Commissioner v. Banks. Whether you can deduct the fee depends on the type of claim.
Can I deduct attorney fees from a settlement?
Sometimes. An above-the-line deduction is generally available for fees in unlawful discrimination and employment cases and certain whistleblower cases, and business-related fees are generally deductible as business expenses. The miscellaneous itemized deduction for other personal legal fees has been permanently eliminated.
What did the Tax Court decide in Eiler v. Commissioner?
In July 2026, the Tax Court held that taxpayers who settled Fair Credit Reporting Act claims were taxable on the full settlement, including amounts paid directly to their lawyers. The court also held that the claims did not qualify for the above-the-line deduction for unlawful discrimination claims.
Are attorney fees taxable in a personal injury settlement?
Generally not, if the underlying damages are excluded as compensation for a physical injury or physical sickness. The fee problem arises mainly with taxable recoveries.
Why did I and my lawyer both get a Form 1099?
Defendants often report the full settlement to the plaintiff and the fee portion to the attorney. Both forms can be correct; what matters is how you report the income and any available deduction on your own return.
Does the settlement agreement affect how attorney fees are taxed?
It can. An express allocation that matches the claims can support excluding or deducting part of the recovery. A silent agreement, as in Eiler, generally leaves the full amount presumed taxable.
About the author
Otto Bosch is a tax controversy attorney at Kugelman Law and a former IRS Revenue Agent from the Global High Wealth group of the IRS Large Business & International (LB&I) Division. He is admitted to practice before the U.S. Tax Court and in Missouri, is an IRS Enrolled Agent, and holds an LL.M. in Taxation.
Otto was quoted in Tax Notes in 2026 on IRS examination training and the LB&I audit campaign targeting deferred legal fee structures. His practice focuses on IRS audit defense, high-net-worth examinations, and U.S. Tax Court litigation.
He works alongside founder Alex Kugelman, a former judicial law clerk at the U.S. Tax Court with nearly two decades of federal tax controversy experience.
This article is attorney advertising and general information, not legal advice. The tax treatment of a settlement and of attorney fees depends on the specific claims, the agreement, and current law. Contacting Kugelman Law does not create an attorney-client relationship.

